| Platinum | Costa's Mediterranean Cafe |
| Gold | Taziki's Mediterranean Cafe |
| Silver | Eli's Jerusalem Grill |
| Bronze | Makarios Kabobs & Grill |
| Top Pick | Bellini's Ristorante & Bar |
| Top Pick | Bottega Italian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Johnny's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | The Olive Branch |
| Top Pick | The Original Pita Stop |
| Top Pick | The Purple Onion Deli & Grill |