| Platinum | Frozen Rooster |
| Gold | Bright Star Restaurant |
| Silver | Half Shell Oyster House |
| Bronze | Seafood King |
| Top Pick | Cousins Maine Lobster |
| Top Pick | Crawdaddy's |
| Top Pick | Fish Market |
| Top Pick | Jubilee Joe's |
| Top Pick | Nawlins Style Po’Boys |
| Top Pick | The Cajun Seafood House |